Introduction
Squirrels can become a nuisance when they invade homes, attics, and gardens. Squirrel trapping is one method to control their presence, but it’s important to understand the advantages and drawbacks. Different trap types exist, from kill traps (which we do not recommend) to humane alternatives, each with varying levels of effectiveness. Before choosing a solution, homeowners should consider the risk to non-target animals, pets, and even children.

Pros of Using a Squirrel Trap
Effectiveness in Removing Squirrels
A well-placed squirrel trap can be highly effective in capturing Eastern grey squirrels and other nuisance wildlife. As long as the squirrels or other wildlife are living outside and not already in your roof or ceiling, traps can be an easy solution. Humane traps allow homeowners to get rid of unwanted animals quick and easy, especially when paired with the right bait, such as fruit, peanut butter, tuna, or nuts.
Versatility for Different Situations
There are multiple types of traps available, including spring-trigger mechanisms, live traps, and lethal kill traps. Having said that, we do not condone kill traps. Lethal traps are not advisable, once you bait and set it on the ground it could attract and maim other animals. Animals are everywhere, and they are valuable to our eco-system, they shouldn’t be killed just for existing. Some traps use mechanisms that can ‘stick’ to an animal upon activation, ensuring quick and effective capture. Depending on the severity of the problem, homeowners can choose the best option for their property and location, whether it’s the ground, attic, or garden.
Humane Capture and Release Options
For those who take the humane approach, live traps allow for the safe release of squirrels away from the home. Squirrels should be set free within one km from site of capture. When traps are properly installed, they minimize harm to the animals while preventing further damage to the property.

Cons of Using Squirrel Traps
Risk to Non-Target Animals and Pets
One major concern with trapping is the potential danger to non-target animals, including pets and birds. A trap set in an accessible area may accidentally spring and could harm unintended species, increasing the need for regular checks to ensure the right animal is caught.
Challenges with Lethal Traps and Poison
While fatal traps and poison may seem like a quick solution, they pose significant risks to grey squirrels. Using poison can lead to secondary poisoning of other wildlife, children, and household pets. In many areas, lethal methods must be handled by certified professionals to ensure proper use.
Repeated Trapping May Be Necessary
Even if one squirrel is caught, it does not mean the problem is solved. More grey squirrels may find their way into the attic or safe place, requiring multiple squirrel removal traps and continuous monitoring. If access points are not closed up, new squirrels will replace the ones removed, making trapping a temporary fix.
Best Practices for Using Squirrel Traps
Proper Placement and Setup
To increase the success rate, install the trap on the ground, and set it in high-traffic areas where squirrels are most active. Using attractive bait, like peanut butter, and ensuring the trigger mechanism functions properly will improve effectiveness for catching squirrels.
Regular Checks and Safe Handling

Once a trap is set, it must be checked time after time to prevent unnecessary suffering for the caught animal. If using a live trap, setting it free in a timely manner and safe location is essential.
Long-Term Solutions Beyond Trapping
While traps can possibly help reduce the immediate problem, preventing future infestations is key. When you’ve found you’re in need of squirrel removal help, call Wildlife Control for easy solutions. Entry points will be blocked with a strong mesh or metal sheet, one way doors will be installed, and squirrel babies, if present, will be removed by hand the same day. A combination of exclusion techniques for squirrels provides the best long-term results.
Conclusion
A squirrel trap can be an effective tool for managing infestations, but it’s important to weigh the pros and cons. The risk to other animals, the need for repeated trapping, and ethical considerations should all be factored into the decision. Whether using humane traps or lethal traps, homeowners should ensure the method is safe, legal, and practical for their property.
